=
| Reviews Vienna, Austria Wiener Stadthalle, Halle D November 12, 2026 |
Review by Max
Vienna 1 - A wonderful concert. But in light of what was to unfold the
following evening, I'd rather leave it at that.
Vienna 2 - A transcendent concert. Dylan walks onstage with the band,
and the audience in the main hall is noticeably more euphoric than it was
on the first night. Things get going straight away. The volume is just
right - considerably more agreeable than in Dusseldorf, where it was
far too low, or Milan, where it was still a little on the quiet side. But
above all, his voice has finally been brought back to the forefront of the
mix, exactly where it belongs. Like a saw blade, it cuts through the sound
of this extraordinarily tight band.
What can I say? Every syllable of every song - with one exception,
"Jimmy Reed" - is delivered with a vocal freedom that never
sacrifices precision. Each note seems to find its place effortlessly. You
can almost feel how the band remains alert to every nuance, never
distracted for a single second. It comes across in Fig's syncopated
drumming, in the wild guitar exchanges between Lage and Paterson, and in
Garnier's deeply soulful bass playing. Dylan's impeccable delivery
keeps bringing to mind the timing and technical command of an
exceptionally gifted rapper.
But perhaps what is most astonishing is the way the new-old arrangements
of "Not Dark Yet" and "Highwater" suddenly seem to have found
their definitive form. As if Dylan had never played anything else in his
life, as if these songs had always existed in this particular incarnation,
like ballads passed down through the centuries. The same is true of
practically everything else that evening, and this even applies to
"Watching the River Flow". Not for a moment is it treated as a mere
warm-up number. Dylan gives it his full attention, his voice wholly
invested in every line.
And speaking of his singing: there is such tenderness, such devotion, such
sorrow for a life slowly drawing to its close in every cadence, every
breath, every turn of phrase, every pause. This is someone singing to the
Creator.
Time and again, the hall erupts in collective euphoria. Particularly when
Julian Lage brings one of his melancholic, virtuosic solos to a close with
almost supernatural precision, landing on the very millisecond Dylan comes
back in. This is tightness in its most exquisite form. Of course, such
precision would be utterly pointless if the musicians were merely
interested in displaying what they can do. Here, virtuosity serves
something else entirely: the timelessness of the songs themselves.
And unlike in Vienna 1 and Milan, Dylan now makes his intentions
unmistakably clear to Julian Lage, time and again, right at the beginning
of the songs. Maintaining eye contact, he plays minor-key notes, as if
gently but firmly reminding the guitarist that he has no further use for
Dire Straits-style major-key excursions. What he wants is something more
solemn, more melancholic, more attuned to the emotional substance of the
songs. And Lage understands. More than that: he delivers.
What can I say? I cried through almost the entire concert. And so, it
seemed, did thousands of others in the arena.
A concert for the ages.
Review by Trevor Townson
Lights of Autumn Tour...
Well no album yet of that title so far as I am aware, but what do I know
with me only being very much a part time fan now. Actually me even
claiming to being a part time fan now would probably be more than a bit of
an overly generous exaggeration on my part, not least due to the extensive
effort that Bob Dylan has put into completing the "Rough & Rowdy Ways
Tour" since the last concert that I attended which was Leeds 2025. Well
with me now being in semi Retirement I guess that I have an excuse for now
also being a semi follower of Bob Dylan. Not sure however that Bob Dylan
would accept Retirement or even semi Retirement as an excuse. Well I am
probably fairly sure that Bob Dylan would not find Retirement or even semi
Retirement an acceptable excuse, Retirement not being a word in his
dictionary, how could Bob Dylan ever comprehend Retirement. Whilst Bob
Dylan is not officially a poet laureate he does have a Nobel Prize in
Literature so he will obviously have a very diverse and extensive
dictionary in his armoury so my guess would be that it would probably be
unwise for most people to compete with him in a Scrabble contest. That
said however, whilst words such as Renewal, Revival, Regenerate and of
course Reborn, Rewrite and Rephrase would certainly be included in the
dictionary of Bob Dylan, I am not overly sure that Retirement would be a
word included in his R section. For instance Bob Dylan did not write
"When I Paint My Masterpiece After Retirement", not least because it
doesn't rhyme. Here is a question for all you Dylanologists out there -
name a song where Bob Dylan has used the word "Retirement" in the
lyrics. Please send your answers to the "Will Bob Dylan Ever Reach
Retirement Competition", answers on a postcard c/o Bill Pagel. I am
not sure, but Bill Pagel may be totally snow bound at this point in the
year so no chance of even the Pony Express reaching him never mind any
latter day postal worker being able to get through in order to deliver any
post cards. But no matter just give it a go, there is no prize anyway,
unless perhaps you are so shallow that you are able to accept looking smug
with yourself as a prize, if in fact you do know where in the lyrics of
Bob Dylan the word Retirement is actually used. Please note that even
with no tangible prize the competition rules state that any Industry
Professionals, Dylan Impersonators, Clinton Heylin and of course Bob Dylan
himself (In Person) are ineligible to enter. One exception of course
being Simon Cowell who did not even know that it was Bob Dylan who had
written "Make You Feel My Love". I believe that he may have thought
that it was an Adele composition so Simon will obviously not have a clue,
as such I am quite happy for that particular Industry Professional to have
a go should he wish to chip in. By default Simon Cowell actually wins the
prize that is on offer anyway as he is the man who never fails to look
anything but smug with himself. Surely Bob Dylan, the ultimate music
industry wordsmith, must have used the word Retirement in his lyrics
somewhere? I have that book Bob Dylan Lyrics 1962-2001 (or is that
1692-2001) and that book is 610 pages long so no chance of me ever going
to get through that lot even with me now being in semi Retirement. That
book is also over 25 years old and as such probably also about best part
of 20 albums worth of lyrics out of date as well by now so even that could
not be used as a definitive guide for reference. Bob Dylan recorded and
performed numerous cover songs latter day and throughout his career
leading up to his Retirement (future tense) so of course the lyrics in any
of those songs are also on the ineligible list in the word search and as
such would not be valid as a competition entry. When I was last in Vienna
I was dressed in a business suit and seated in the comfort of a corporate
company car being chauffeured quickly and efficiently from Factory to
Airport while all the time doing nothing other than probably pondering the
joys of Retirement, when I could just be sat in comfort, doing nothing and
getting paid for it! The Royal Festival Hall on 8th December which is
actually on my birthday is the show that I should be doing more than any
other on this tour but unfortunately I could not secure a premium ticket
for that one so here I am again in Vienna instead. I have actually been to
see a concert previously in Austria but that show was in Linz but it did
give me my first taste of the historical musical culture of the country
plus my first glimpse of the Danube. But this time with an extra show, not
one but two nights with the bard himself, in the City of Music, the Waltz
Capital, the home of the Strauss Dynasty who for years were at competitive
pains with each other, not least due to which one of them could adorn the
most outrageously flamboyant moustache. Really I do not know why I
attempt to write a review as I never have anything to offer either
musically or lyrically about the songs like some of the other reviewers
do. I do not know what key the songs are being played in, neither do I
care, I do not know what the true meaning of any particular song is,
neither do I care, I do not know what instruments are being played,
neither do I care, now I do not even know who the guitarists are, and
guess what, neither do I care. The only care I do have is that it is Bob
Dylan on stage and that is the only reason for me being there, I will
leave it up to him to make the choices of what he wants to perform, how he
wants to deliver it, what key he wants to play it in, which instruments he
wants to use and which band members he wants to employ. That said I guess
that I had better attempt a bit of a review like other reviewers do
otherwise why bother. Some reviewers do a song by song account, some
reviewers do a where song last played, some reviewers do a when song last
played, some reviewers do a number of times a song has been played, some
reviewers do songs they like best, some reviewers do songs they do not
like best. After all that there is not a lot left for me to add so what
bit could there be remaining for me to do. So just what bit could I add
this time here in Vienna, with limited musical knowledge and review
capacity, even walking in the presence of the ghosts of so many giants of
Classical music in the City of Vienna, where for centuries performances
have been held by composers and musicians having the absolute highest of
high in musical ability, all whilst being listened to and judged by the
most discerning of talented and educated musical ears, where even the rare
inclusion of a demisemihemidemisemiquaver if played ever so slightly too
quickly would be sure to arouse more than just the one raised eye brow
from within the audience. The only classical musician that I know that
is included in the present band is Tony Garnier, I know that because I
have sometimes seen him holding a big violin. Seen him playing it too many
times but I cannot say that I have ever heard it as unfortunately it just
seems to get drowned out by the louder modern instruments so it would
certainly be absolutely impossible for me to discern a 256th note if Tony
ever included one. May be one day they could Amp Tony up a bit (or
whatever the technical term is), to make him louder so that those like me
could probably hear the big violin a little better. I think that I may
have occasionally discerned the odd thud or two and may be the occasional
twang or perhaps even a whine but don't hold me to that by asking me
when and where, remember this is not a proper review. Perhaps I should try
to listen better, or perhaps that is the problem, may be it is only a
problem for me and my ears so I will just have to live with the loss.
Perhaps all those more discerning, talented and educated musical ears in
the audience can hear every note, beat, thud, twang and whine that Tony is
playing. Myself I have always been of the impression that only Bob can
hear the big Violin properly with him mostly being seated nearest to it,
may be it really is so good when you can actually hear it properly that
perhaps it is Bob who is just keeping it all to himself. Probably time for
undertaking a little research, time perhaps to educate myself better on
the big Violin. Well firstly I find that is not the proper technical term,
the instrument does have many different names the most commonly used being
stand-up bass or double bass. Then eureka, I may have found my answer
already, as it is the lowest-pitched chordophone (don’t ask) in the
modern symphony orchestra. So that must be the reason why I cannot hear
it, whilst it has been noted that I have particularly acute hearing, OK
maybe not in the same league as the greater wax moth but probably nearer
to a dog than the average human and probably audibly more of a child than
an adult. The answer must be that the instrument is simply not in my
hearing spectrum, so absolutely no use in employing any extra
amplification as I would still probably not discern such a low pitch. My
hearing is probably more suited to a feedback shriek than it is to any
note, beat, thud, twang or whine that Tony could offer me. Well that was
worth the effort of putting in the research, there was I for years
watching Tony standing up there on stage apparently doing nothing, but
surely how silly would that be as even I could do that. But there is more,
get this, unlike an electric bass guitar the double base has a fretless
fingerboard, the finger board has no frets meaning the player must rely on
muscle memory (don't ask) and ear training for accurate intonation
(again don't ask). What on earth is muscle memory, is it something you
are born with rather than able to learn how to do, perhaps it is akin to
being born as an Arctic Tern who from birth instinctively knows when and
where to fly without ever having received any tuition. One further
conclusion from my research is that surely no amount of tutoring could
ever turn someone into a double bass player, absolutely impossible, surely
playing such an instrument even if you could hear it just could not be
taught, you must definitely have to be born into the instrument in some
kind of instinctive way. After all these years attending and watching
Tony, listening to but not hearing Tony, I can now categorically state
that I now view Tony Garnier as an absolute genius for what he is able to
do, and if I could borrow his hat I would take it off to him. Actually,
rather than Tony being musically audible to me, or to pull off a two
five six as the musically uneducated would put it, I would much prefer
Tony to "have a good book in him". Instead of "Chronicles" The
Pope could then be handed the "Book of Tony", from the disciple who
has been at the right hand (and left hand) of the master for so many
years. I wonder if the Pope said to Bob after dusting down the book,
"Should you not be on Volume Three by now, or are you saving that for
your Retirement?" So without going into every timbre and cadence,
crotchet and quaver, or hopefully any statements of facts here is my
particular take on things, but firstly I do actually have one statement of
fact which may or may not prove to be correct. Thus far to the point of
writing there has been 15 Shows with, apart from just the one exception, a
17 or 18 Song set list, there has however been 35 Songs performed so it is
not exactly so standard a set list this tour as it may at first glance
appear to be. I do remember back in day knowing fans who would have done
every show but not sure that there could be any fan still doing that now,
or even able to do that now, as such no one person is probably going to be
able to claim having witnessed the full spectrum of all 35 songs whilst
being performed live. Not sure that all of the guitarists can even claim
that but who can keep up with those statistics. Back in the past there
were far more GA shows in a tour making it more feasible and worthwhile to
do multiple shows, where with sufficient time and effort an upfront(ish)
position night on night was a possibility at a pretty do able price. Now
pretty soon the bank balance of most is soon maxed out for a fraction of
the same experience. Even if your bank balance is not maxed out, even mine
had a bit more stretch in it, no one could be quick enough to get five
night on night London shows anymore, well seemingly not a single London
night up front anymore. However I did actually manage to purchase four
front row seats for this tour, the first two being for these two shows in
Vienna. Only if you are an ordinary punter trying to get premium front of
house seats these days will you appreciate just how difficult it is to do
so. Even having a lottery winning bank balance does not necessarily help
either. Luck cannot be relied on as that is taking too much of a chance.
So strategy was to be my approach this time so luck would not need to come
into it, just make sure to go on line promptly at the appointed time (the
correct time, this time!) and get your tickets, a bit costly but consider
it a Retirement treat, sorry I mean a semi Retirement treat. It is the
day of the sale and approaching the appointed time, this time I am
properly ready and have things planned like a military operation. Computer
on, Second computer on (in case of failure of first computer), Credit
cards lined up, Debit cards lined up (in case of failure of credit cards
or more likely credit cards getting blocked by the bank because I never
usually spend so much). Having watched the computer screen for a couple of
hours, now the time is really getting close, the anticipation builds as
the seconds continue to count down on the digital ticketing site clock,
whilst watching each second tick by it really gets you thinking, "why do
seconds take so long when you are watching them", now though it is very
nearly time, well into the last hour, time for some final preparations,
take medication for the headache, mop down the brow, the last few
remaining seconds start ticking down, Five, Four, three, Two, One LONDON
SHOW FRONT ROW - SOLD OUTLONDON SHOW FRONT ROW - SOLD OUTLONDON SHOW
FRONT ROW _ SOLD OUTLONDON SHOW FRONT ROW _ SOLD OUTLONDON SHOW
FRONT ROW - SOLD OUTLONDON SHOW GOLD TICKET - SOLD OUTLONDON SHOW GOLD
TICKET - SOLD OUTLONDON SHOW GOLD TICKET - SOLD OUTLONDON SHOW GOLD TICKET
- SOLD OUTLONDON SHOW GOLD TICKET - SOLD OUT This I believe was not just
unique to London, I would also have been very interested to get tickets
for Blackpool but I think the screen looked the same for those shows too.
I cannot be certain to the exact second on that one though as I must have
wasted some time by gazing at the screen looking at the London dates for
at least a second in disbelief, then may be for another second in total
disbelief, so perhaps Blackpool was at one stage up for sale if you were
able to measure the time using an atomic clock, but I am still not even
convinced of that. The premium tickets for the UK dates all sold rapidly
if not instantly, if in fact some ever existed for sale at all, having
said that I did manage to secure front row at Birmingham and Sheffield in
the panic sale that ensued, no time to mop the brow during that, the sweat
just had to be left dripping. The European dates were not so quick to sell
out so there was still opportunity to now mop the brow and browse those
shows to see if anything took your fancy. Vienna stood out and took my
fancy, specifically because of all the other places on the tour, well
apart from in the UK, Vienna was the only other place offering more than
the one show at the same venue, so Vienna it would have to be, so two
further ticket sales and I am good to go. What a show, I mean shows,
where has this come from, where has that voice come from. I once stuck my
neck out by saying in a review words to the effect that "Bob Dylan is a
good singer and does have a good voice, but he is just not using it
properly", well he has proved that particular statement to be true as he
is certainly using it properly now. Not on just the odd song, but all
songs being given the same care, this was as far away as you could get
from a going through the motions performance. Different arrangements for
many of the songs, but of course this is nothing new and probably almost
expected now, but this time the rearrangements seem to change them into
totally different songs altogether rather than just a different
presentation of the same song. Fantastic harmonica, I certainly heard
that, now that was pitched perfectly for my ears, I was actually quite
surprised as I did not expect Bob to have harmonica like that still in
him, as good as the best I have previously heard, spontaneous and
wonderfully piercing, there were certainly no signs of any frailty in
those outbursts. Bob was standing at the key board for quite a lot of the
time, front facing and not hiding away too much under the hoody, certainly
from close up you could say that he was acceptably prominent, also fairly
animated too as he used his arms to signal out instructions to the band.
The guitarists were good and loud so I could hear them, the drums too so I
suppose I heard most of the drumming but may be not all of the lower pitch
sounds. Others have said how tight the band is, I think I know what that
means so will just agree to agree with them, anyway it was more than good
enough for me. For me the highlight of these two shows was definitely Tony
Garnier on double base, and that is saying a lot after having said earlier
that I could not hear him, but you know in my own way in the end I did.
During the second night I found a way to hear most every note. Both nights
I was blessed with an especially good seat, not the same seat for both
shows but only a few apart, however that slight differing in position
proved so important to further my musical exploration. I had an equally
good view of Bob on both nights, actually as good as you could get, so
that was ticket paid for even at a premium front row price tag, it also
made every second of watching two hours worth of very long seconds ticking
by on that ticketing site worth every second of effort, if there is a pun
in that, no pun intended. The significant factor of the slightly
different seat spacing was that it gave me different views of Tony. Due to
the positioning of some front of stage boxes, first night I could only see
the top of Tony and his left hand, you know the clever blind one relying
on muscle memory, and having to work without the benefit of any frets as
an aid to knowing where your fingers should be. Believe me as much as I
was trying and straining to hear I cannot recall hearing much at all if
anything from the double base on first night. I was however amazed
watching the movement and positioning as Tony worked with his left hand, I
could definitely see from his fascial expressions that he could hear
perfectly every note that his left hand was creating, I also inferred from
the interaction with Bob that Mr Dylan too could also hear everything that
Tony had to say with his left hand. Second night gave an alternative
view due to the ever so slightly different seat positioning. Now I could
see Tony full on from the top down so this was going to be a fantastic
opportunity to expand my musical exploration on the workings of the double
bass. Initially there appeared to be some problem with the set up as Tony
seemed concerned with something as he interrupted his playing to tweak
things on the stage mounted electronics box. Tony seemed to be suffering
like me with a sound issue but soon a roadie appears on stage to assist
him and the issue seems to be quickly resolved from there. Now this time,
second night, I can see both hands, whilst first night I was getting
nothing from seeing the left hand alone, tonight it was different by
seeing both left and right hands together I could "see" the music, it
was a kind of deaf equivalent to being blind if that makes sense. I also
found that by seeing the playing I could hear some of the music better
too, still a strain but I was getting something through rather than
silence. Also on the quieter songs with the bow I could hear better then,
but I do not think that I would have heard it without seeing it as well. I
heard almost nothing on the first night and by not seeing the right hand I
never knew a bow was even used on the first night, if indeed it was. I
think it was due to the length of sound the bow created that it gave me
the time to tune into it, also those songs seemed slower and quieter
overall which helped. Best of all was the finger work during Goodbye Jimmy
Reed which was truly amazing to listen to, I mean watch. How can anyone do
that, fret less too! Everything was so fast and loud, fingers almost a
blur, I could not discern a thing sound wise from the double bass during
that but I did not need to, it was so incredible to just to watch all that
movement, through seeing the movements the sounds somehow came silently
through to me. So with my musical exploration drawing to a close, again I
had experienced my second ticket paid for moment, well perhaps a half
ticket paid for, sorry Tony, not really a reflection on you or your
playing and I really enjoyed "hearing" you for once, but it was
afterall a pretty expensive ticket. Not really fair or even relevant in
review to state stand out songs because for most people there will no
doubt be many stand out and special songs in any given performance, also
songs are so personal. Some people may like cheese, other people may not,
so does that make cheese bad, no, it is just not to everyones taste, some
will like cheese a lot, others not so much, perhaps some not at all. A
song is not intrinsically good or bad, it relies on the individual
listener to decide that. My own personal stand out song was Sugar Baby.
Definitely a song not to everyones taste it would seem. Strange how in an
earlier review from Italy it was said about this song "almost no one in
the audience recognised". Also in the same review reference was made to
all the hype on the internet due to resuscitation of this particular song.
As said, songs are personal and for me this song is from a particularly
special time and place and album so gave me opportunity for some
reflective thoughts as it was delivered perfectly with my mind wandering
back to some past times and many long lost Summer Days. If you ever got
your Pope moment and had the opportunity to be in the presence of Bob
Dylan to ask a question, mine would be "Please explain the song Sugar
Baby, what is the song really about, the real meaning, the hidden meaning,
the subtle meaning, me knowing only the gross meaning that I infer through
my ignorance I now seek the truth" You would then be given a very
measured and lengthy explanation following which, having received your
audience and been given your answer you would then leave the room, closing
the door softly behind you as you walk quietly away thinking -"Still not
got a bloody clue". But does it matter, does the question need asking
in the first place, the song is for you, it is your song for you to make
of the song whatever fits with you, with your life and with your own
particular circumstances. Just accept the song as a personal gift to you,
take the song and make of it what you want and just take enjoyment from
it, there is no divine help available or needed. My view is to best just
draw your own conclusions, failing that go find a good double bass player
to "listen" to instead. By the way, did anyone get a post card off to
Bill Pagel for the "Will Bob Dylan Ever Reach Retirement Competition".
No? Well I guess that means there are no winners for that particular
competition, so that only leaves Simon Cowell as usual looking smug, so no
change there then. Simon having now found out that there is a Bob Dylan
song that he actually likes, will also probably look very smug again
whilst sitting front row at The Royal Festival Hall. No doubt surrounded
by his special guest list of twelve who he has invited in order to see up
close the new prodigy that he is considering signing up. Well I have
been lucky enough to be in that seat already a few times now, so it is
only fair to give someone else the opportunity. There was a guy from
London sat behind me at the first Vienna show and I over heard him talking
to the person sat beside him that he had tried for London tickets but they
Sold Out straight away, so like me he also found himself having to venture
further afield onto the Continent in order to get up close. Knowing that
this time I had been right on time for purchasing a premium ticket for the
8th, but still failed. I thought, "You know what, I do not think that
those tickets were ever available for sale", "Unless of course you
look smug enough to get one", but under fear of any legal proceedings
for liable I kept that particular thought to myself. Well at least I
have been there and done that, even if never having worn the tee shirt.
Anyway I am almost forgetting that I am only in semi Retirement and
probably working on that day and I am not too sure that I am due anymore
time off in order to attend, and I am not too sure that attending a Bob
Dylan show would qualify for compassionate leave. May be for Bob Dylan
there will be no Retirement, may be not even a day off to blow out
candles. Who can tell, all we know is that Bob Dylan is not in Retirement
yet, may be he will not be in Retirement next year, may be he will not be
in Retirement for some years after that, may be he will perform after
Thanks Giving again, may be he will perform on the 8th again, may be he
will perform in Vienna again rather than perform in The Royal Festival
Hall again, if so may be both myself and that guy from London may actually
get a premium ticket again. Next stops for me are in the UK in Birmingham
and Sheffield which were found for some reason not to be immediately
totally SOLD OUT in the first second, but believe me it certainly did not
take too much longer. Just a suspicion but may be not all of the "music
royalty" like traveling too far out of London, if so, their loss could
be my gain provided of course that I am very quick about it. For all fans
past, present and no doubt future, lets just all hope that Bob Dylan never
adopts Retirement either as a word in his lyrics or as a life choice, but
should he decide so to do I feel certain that all our best wishes would be
with him and no body would deserve Retirement more, but hopefully he will
keep on working, "Cause there's not any man that done the things that
he done" Brilliant!
| Click Here to return to the Main Page |
page by Bill Pagel
billp61@boblinks.com
| Current Tour Guide |
Older Tour Guides |
Bob Links Page |
Songs Performed |
Set Lists by Date |
Set Lists by Location |
Cue Sheets |