November 21, 2019
Review by David Steinert
Me and my wife drove to Philadelphia from New Jersey to see bob for the
first time this tour ! What a show Dylan did tonight not only did
lightning strike it struck the whole night ! This was our first show with
new band and it was great . ( miss George ) Bob was incredible just my
highlights north country with little of band just piano and bob singing
one of the best performance I’ve ever seen . I saw people with tears in
their eyes . Bobs voice was beautiful. Not dark amazing. Roman kings
crushing it . Pay in blood is a pretty mean tune and bob sung it like he
meant it like he was scorning the front row spitting out the lyrics like
he wanted vengeance. The met is a great venue last there opening night
last year for bob venue sound is great all sight lines great . The entire
audience even the fair weather fans stood and cheered the whole last two
songs . People ask me my whole life how can you go to so many Dylan shows
? I say if I could watch Monet paint I stand by next to him and watch him
paint all day .If I could watch Poe write I stand by his desk every chance
. Tonight I watched the greatest most creative artist of modern times do
his craft . Mind blowing. See you at the beacon
Review by Tom Karel
This was Bob's return visit to The Met Philadelphia, a venerable old opera house
(c. 1908) on North Broad Street. My daughter and I were there last December
when Bob and his band opened the newly restored venue. That was a very
very good show. Thursday's performance was much better. Here's why:
Bob's voice is more melodic and more powerful - equally effective on the
hard-rocking songs, the snarling songs, and the softer songs. This was
especially true on the songs he sang standing center stage, usually without an
instrument. He prowled around, leaned into the mic stands, made pointed
gestures, and delivered his lines with intense passion and precision. You
couldn't take your eyes off him. He did seven songs this way and each was a
treat. Last year he only performed one song standing - "Scarlet Town" - and
that was definitely a highlight of that show.
In 2018 Bob sat at a grand piano for all but one of the songs. This year he
pounded on an upright piano instead - sitting for some songs and standing for
others. When he stood at the piano he suddenly seemed younger and
attacked the keys with a vengeance. He played a harmonica a few times
which the crowd appreciated, and the guitar twice. A good variety of
musical approaches.
Dylan knows his songs well before he starts singing. He is comfortable with this
set. The songs suit his voice and he wants to sing them, for reasons unknown
to us. Several popular staples from last year's tour are no longer played (Blowin'
in the Wind, Like a Rolling Stone, Don't Think Twice) and you really don't miss
them. However, I'm sure many of the casual fans in the crowd were hoping to
hear more of his "greatest hits."
The band knows these songs well, too. The mix of the veterans and the new
guys adds a newfound energy to the overall pleasure and sound of the show.
Charlie Sexton was fun to watch, though as I said it was hard to take my eyes
of Bob.
Location, location, location. Last year our seats were high up on the side, as
high as you could get in The Met. We had a good view of the entire stage but
the action was far away. This time we had great seats - in the eighth row on
the left. We had a good sightline to the stage (in spite of some large people in
front of us) and the way the piano was positioned allowed us to see Bob's
every move. Those sitting on the right side of the theater saw the back of
the upright piano unless Bob was standing.
A couple other observations. Sitting so close made me realize how old Bob is.
His face looks haggard. He moves slowly, and is bent over a bit. For some of
the standing songs he used a mic stand as a kind of crutch. But his voice was
strong and he gave it his all. This was his third night in a row - Lowell to
Providence to Philadelphia - so he might have been a little tired. He also
looked happy and talked a lot with the band between songs. I was glad that
he introduced the band - something he stopped doing for several years.
Security was very heavy in the theater. We were warned going in that
"no cell phone use" was allowed. Period. Before the show I started sending
a text to my wife at my seat and a security guy appeared instantly and politely
repeated the policy. I had to go out into the lobby to finish the text. We
saw dozens of instances where people were told to put their phones away -
and that was before the show started. Only a couple people dared use their
phones during the show - including one guy sitting behind us. You couldn't
even take photos before the show.
People gave Bob standing ovations after every song, and almost everyone
stood during the two encores. I felt compelled to stand and cheer after a
rousing "Highway 61" and an incredible "Early Roman Kings." The other
highlights for me were: a nicely revamped "Can't Wait"; a powerful and
venomous "Pay in Blood"; the emotionally moving combo of "Girl from the
North Country" and "Not Dark Yet"; and the rollicking "Gotta Serve
Somebody." The rest of the songs were top-notch as well, even lesser
tunes like "Honest with Me" and "Make You Feel My Love." I had a little
trouble hearing Bob's voice in the first two songs but then the sound mix
improved and the rest of the show was fine.
Speaking of standing, there was a large group of fans in front to the left of
us who stood and danced for about half of the show. A young woman,
whose view was blocked, got upset and talked to security and everyone
had to sit down. When that happened a lot of other people who couldn't
see loudly cheered. This was in the middle of one of the songs but it
didn't throw Bob off one bit. My daughter later told me that she thought
there was going to be a fight between the woman who complained and
someone else. I didn't notice any of that; I was too focused on the artist
on the stage.
When we got outside the tour buses were getting ready to leave the side
lot and head down Broad Street so we watched them go. People were
waving and taking photos. We did, too. Thanks for an amazing evening,
Bob!
Tom Karel
Lancaster, PA
Review by Adam Dean
Mixed emotions, joy and sadness, anticipation, excitement and a sense of
loss - Bob Dylan & His Band were in the room last night at The Met, the
simply fantastic concert venue in downtown Philadelphia, but sadly Peter
Stone Brown was not; we recently lost Peter after a long illness and he
was simply there in spirit. But Bob Dylan was there and he put on a great
show, very slick and professional, a whistle-stop on the way from there to
here and off to NYC for a residency run of shows. This time around finds
Bob in enhanced "crooner" mode, having taken the stage-moves honed on
Sinatra into his main stage act, as he crouches down by the drum kit,
microphone in hand then jumps to center-stage to deliver biting lyrics on
songs such as Not Dark Yet, Can't Wait and Pay In Blood. There is also the
"piano man" with Bob singing clearly on beautiful ballads such as Girl Of
The North Country, It Ain't Me Babe, Trying To Get To Heaven and Soon
After Midnight. And "rocker" Bob kicking the guitar
around the stage on Things Have Changed and Ballad Of A Thin Man. The
musicians with Bob are, as always, "some of the finest players in the
country" and Charlie Sexton and Tony Garnier power the louder songs like
Highway 61, Early Roman Kings, and Honest With Me.
Interesting stage set-up, gone are the carpets and incense - we have 3
mannequins dressed in 1920's finery (think Great Gatsby) at stage rear,
Bob's piano front-stage right center leaving stage left open for him to
crouch and croon.
My personal highlight was Lenny Bruce, a song I had never heard performed
in 45 years of seeing Dylan shows, and it was delivered in a lovely ballad
with the words clear and eloquent - bringing dear departed Peter to mind;
Lenny Bruce is gone. But Bob remains on the Never Ending Tour and it's
always a great thrill to catch a glimpse.
Lights down at 8:02 PM and off-the-stage by 9:46 PM, no openers, no
intermission. As the advertisements say, "Don't You Dare Miss It" and
don't be late!
Review by Laurette Maillet
Philadelphia. Back to where I started beginning of September this year but
this time a Bob Dylan show is programmed at the MET again, the same as
last year. Ben and I managed to drop the rented car at JFK just on time
and full of gas, a miracle by itself as the traffic jam started 50 miles
ahead of New York NY crossing The Bronx and The Queens. We have few hours
to kill before our bus to Philly is due so we sit outside on the stairs of
Penn Station ,(with a crowd of pigeons) facing the Madison Square Garden.
We share memories of the "Hurricane Tour". We split arriving in Philly;
Ben goes to his hostel, I walk straight to the MET. Just on time to see
the buses pulling in for the soundcheck. Cool! They are all here. I spend
time recharging my phone batteries in a Cafe and walk back to the MET. Ben
and I need tickets(again!). We are confident. The crowd is friendly and
relatively young, younger than the "campus" crowds(?!). I manage to sell
one of my little paintings. A couple of nice friendly Fans, Josh and
Michelle, offer Ben and I two tickets side by side. I immediately propose
one of my paintings as an exchange and we are all walking inside happy and
joyfully. The spirit I like! No struggle today. Security Bob and Barron ,
I saw them, in a good mood too! The theater is nice and comfy and we have
seats on the first row of the balcony. All the best as the pit seems to be
low in front of the high stage. On time , they take the stage. A roar
from the entire theater makes me feel that will be a tremendous show.
"Things have changed" is opening as brand new to me. The Fans on the floor
are standing up the entire song. The applause is deafening (for good). "It
ain't me Babe" is clear and loud. "Highway 61" put the theater on
fire. Many youngsters are dancing and bouncing even on the aisle, on the
floor, showing that security is relaxed and cool. Bob is torching the
night. The Band is tight. Even if Donnie at some point had a problem
with his violin and Britt made a slight mistake at the beginning of
"Honest with you" : Bob didn't start singing on time, the Band was ready
for another intro... The same on " You've gotta serve somebody " Bob
missed a couple of words. But that just show the spontaneity of the
performance. With Ben we accompany Bob on some lyrics. Specifically
screaming out " I ain't dead yet. My bell still rings..." The echoes of
"Not dark yet" are more subtle tonight, giving a nice resonance to the
words and making the atmosphere even more sepulchral. "Thunder on the
mountain" puts the public on its feet. The solos of Charlie and Britt
are appreciated and applauded. And of course the Bob's harmonicas solos.
This is the best public for a long time. That show is definitively set
for a small theater connoisseurs public. They know what to expect and they
like it. It is over way too soon. An immense roar accompanies Bob back
to the curtains. He knew and spent few more seconds on his bow. He
doesn't want to leave US neither! What a show! What a public! What a day!
My good Friend David already wrote a review. Yes. We had a great time.
Thank you so much Bobby. Thank you the Band. Thank you all the good people
of Philly. See you next year at the MET?
Review by Alexander Leik
It's been a few years since I have submitted a review/personal thoughts on
a Bob show. I've still been attending a few each year, but it became
tiresome to put down my thoughts after arriving home late, and then before
I knew it, a week or more had gone by and it soon became "whats the point,
now?" Well Thursday night at the Met in Philly gave me more than enough
energy, enthusiasm...whatever you want to call it...to get back in the
ring. I had been to Baltimore a week earlier, and a fine show that was as
well. But Bob found the extra gear in Philly. Maybe it was the beautiful
venue (I was lucky enough to see him re-open it Dec 3, 2019 as well).
Maybe it was that extremely energetic Philly crowd pushing him further
(for all the heat they take about being lousy sports fans, they sure know
their music!). Maybe it was a push from above (I feel Peter Stone Brown
would have given a strong nod of approval to this hometown performance).
Our hero is definitely slowing, and the "dance" in this song and dance man
is gradually slipping away. But the "song" was probably the strongest I
have seen in 10 years, maybe more. The voice was on from the words
"worried man with a worried MIND!" and at times he felt the need to lash
out at us (Pay in Blood, Early Roman Kings, Highway 61, Thin Man), often
pointing/stabbing towards the crowd to emphasize his words, as if to say
"listen to me!". Then he would take it back 180 degrees and deliver the
finest singing you've ever heard. North Country was beautiful, and the
interplay between our hero on the ivories and Donnie Heron on violin for
this song was unbelievable, poignant. Simple Twist of Fate & It Ain't Me
Babe also had strong but measured vocals, and the latter is an arrangement
that has developed over the years into a show highlight. But the 5 minutes
that stop the show, same as in Baltimore, continues to be Lenny Bruce.
Whether he really "rooohhhhde with him, in a taxi once" is folklore to
which we may be better off never knowing the truth. But its clear that Bob
feels a connection. There's something autobiographical about the way he
delivers this one in 2019. Its stunning and were I a wealthy, unemployed
man with zero responsibilities, I would spend the next 2 weeks (and a
Thanksgiving) in NYC gladly watching it 10 times over. Might be the best
thing I have ever seen him do, and the Philly crowd was respectfully
quiet, followed by a thunderous roar, recognizing the rare gem that hat
been so perfectly delivered. Let's not forget the machine that helps our
hero deliver night after night. The addition of Bob Britt and replacement
of George Recile by Matt Chamberlain adds something that the band has
needed. I do miss George, the 2nd longest tenured band member ever I
believe? But man, Matt Chamberlain is there for a reason. His fills, snare
work and and just basic tempo work really gives these songs new life. Bob
Britt has a lot of leads on this tour, deservedly so. Donnie has become
the multi-instrumentalist that almost has me saying "Larry/Bucky who?" I
say "almost" because I still miss the vocal harmonies. But Donnie seems to
have become more of Bob's "go to" for cues, possibly due to where Bob is
positioned most of the time, but also because Donnie's seat gives him full
view of the other 4 band members. Charlie and Tony are just so in line
with these songs, with our hero, that there's really no reason to fret as
long as they booth walk out there with him each night. The last time I saw
Charlie in Philly, it was in early summer, in a bar that held about 30
people, playing with Michael Ramos & the great Austin musician (and chef!)
Michael Fracasso. Charlie looks just as comfortable in his little corner
on the stage at the Met as he did that night. And Bob made us all feel
like we were the only ones in the room. 10 nights in NYC and 1 in DC.
Don't you Dare Miss it!
Review by Barry Gloffke
Bob Dylan back on tour with his superb Band. I joined the tour at The Met
Philadelphia, a fabulous refurbished opera house. What a show!
From the opening chords of THINGS HAVE CHANGED (a slower, more subdued
version than previous tours featuring Bob on guitar) to the last howls of
'When your train gets looooooooooooosssssttttt', the show was magnificent.
Each song stood out in its own unique way. As usual Bob threw in some new
lyrics and reworks the melodies... all to great effect. Highlights were
many.
The slow burning ballads such as WHEN I PAINT MY MASTERPIECE, TRYIN' TO
GET TO HEAVEN, MAKE YOU FEEL MY LOVE (simply wonderful), LENNY BRUCE
(wow!) and GIRL FROM THE NORTH COUNTRY (tender and sad) were sung with
sincerity and depth and the interweaving of Donnie, Charlie and Britts'
playing on those songs was fabulous. Truly mesmerizing stuff. These takes
are some of the finest singing Bob has done in years. When the audience
quiets down and lets Bob's singing take over the room... well it's quite
breathtaking. More fine evidence of the reason we follow this man.
Then there were the rockers — HIGHWAY 61 REVISITED (a blow the doors open
version, hard charging guitars and Bob's driving piano took this back to
the 1990s gigs), HONEST WITH ME (a rocking blast), THUNDER ON THE MOUNTAIN
(more like an earthquake on the mountain with a great short drum solo to
cap it off) and GOTTA SERVE SOMEBODY (I love this version so much, great
vocal delivery, dancing in the aisles, a great way to end the set). Tony
and Matt certainly shone bright on these songs and the guitars were on
fire. Not to mention superb piano from Bob.
And how about the new interpretations of CAN'T WAIT (funky delivery,
brilliant vocals, standing center stage like a prizefighter, so damned
good), PAY IN BLOOD (started with an odd melody, but after a minute or so
took off with ripping guitars and a nasty vocal delivery from Dylan) and
NOT DARK YET (Bob commanding the center stage, echo effect, beautiful
strong delivery... delicious)
Lastly were the blues/rockers. Man were these great. The encore numbers of
BALLAD OF A THIN MAN (Bob center stage on guitar) and IT TAKES A LOT TO
LAUGH, IT TAKES TRAIN TO CRY (a great version and I really like that he
ends the concert with this song) were top notch versions. But EARLY ROMAN
KINGS might have been the highlight for me tonight. This song was off the
charts, deep, strong. It felt like old style Chicago blues. Bob was
savaging the lords of the day (sluggers and muggers), serving them
bitterness and bile (tear you limb from limb). 'If you see me coming and
you're standing there, wave your handkerchiefs in the air'... he ain't
dead yet!! ...his bell still rings!! Bravo!
Another brilliant show. Top tier. Dylan in great voice, fine piano
playing, soaring harp and small guitar licks... gotta love it!
Nice to see Ed tonight. Hello to Mike. Thanks for the dances Kathleen. See
you guys at the Beacon.
This was show #52 for me.
Best show ever is still (and probably always will be): Tramps, NYC, July 26, 1999
Click Here to return to the Main Page |
page by Bill Pagel
billp61@execpc.com
Current Tour Guide |
Older Tour Guides |
Bob Links Page |
Songs Performed |
Set Lists by Date |
Set Lists by Location |
Cue Sheets |